Grateful Apparition 
Creature — Spirit
$0.18 #1836 0.18 7.3 years
Flying
Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player or planeswalker, proliferate. (Choose any number of permanents and/or players, then give each another counter of each kind already there.)
Click a line or tag to filter
Cards similar to Grateful Apparition expected a card that isn't here?
Reports become test cases the matcher is graded against before an update ships. Delvefall isn't a chatbot guessing, it compares the printed rules text of every card with plain math, and examples like yours decide which differences should count.
Guildpact Informant100%
$0.54↑#8851↓0.52↑7.3 years
"Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player or planeswalker, proliferate."
Thrummingbird94%
$0.25↑#845↑0.2215.9 years↑
"Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, proliferate."
+1 more matching line
Bloated Contaminator89%
$3.28↑#2593↓0.68↑3.6 years↓
"Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, proliferate."
Vexing Radgull89%
$1.39↑#4734↓0.212.5 years↓
"Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player, that player gets two rad counters if they don't have any rad counters. Otherwise, proliferate."
Atraxa, Praetors' Voice84%
$24.32↑#2475↓1.72↑9.8 years↑
"At the beginning of your end step, proliferate."
Park Heights Maverick80%
$0.40↑#11435↓0.00↓4.4 years↓
"Whenever this creature deals combat damage to a player or dies, proliferate."
Soul Seizer // Ghastly Haunting80%
$0.12↓#24083↓0.00↓14.6 years↑
"Flying"
Urban Daggertooth78%
$0.26↑#10409↓0.07↓5.2 years↓
"Whenever this creature is dealt damage, proliferate."
Contaminant Grafter78%
$13.98↑#3987↓0.45↑3.6 years↓
"Whenever one or more creatures you control deal combat damage to one or more players, proliferate."
Eye Collector78%
$0.16↓#10324↓0.06↓6.9 years
"Flying"
Patrolling Peacemaker77%
$0.63↑#21490.45↑1.1 years↓
"Whenever an opponent commits a crime, proliferate."
Tidus, Yuna's Guardian76%
$0.43↑#3808↓0.45↑1.2 years↓
"Whenever one or more creatures you control with counters on them deal combat damage to a player, you may draw a card and proliferate. Do this only once each turn."
Kelinore Bat76%
$0.09↓#28728↓0.00↓17.1 years↑
"Flying"
Living Tempest76%
$0.08↓#29974↓0.43↑5.9 years↓
"Flying"
Scion of Ugin76%
$0.10↓#23935↓0.40↑11.4 years↑
"Flying"
Millennial Gargoyle76%
$0.09↓#29272↓0.00↓13.6 years↑
"Flying"
Enforcer Griffin76%
$0.07↓#27521↓0.00↓7.3 years
"Flying"
Colorful Feiyi Sparrow76%
$0.24↑#27825↓0.278.2 years
"Flying"
Tormented Angel76%
$0.14↓#28488↓0.00↓27.2 years↑
"Flying"
Wasp Lancer76%
$0.11↓#29330↓0.07↓18.3 years↑
"Flying"