Mutant Menace
The Wise Mothman · PIP 2024 · official decklist · 100 cards
See all 166 Commander precons ranked by most original →
What originality means here
Every card scores 0 to 1: one minus how close its nearest match anywhere in Magic gets, so 0.30 means something out there is 70% like it. A deck's figure is the average across its most original half of nonland cards, so it climbs by holding cards with less competition, never by holding more cards.
- 43 Planar Portal 0.189
- 44 Upgrades Unleashed 0.189
- 45 Avengers Assemble 0.188
- 46 Mutant Menace 0.188
- 47 Death Toll 0.188
- 48 Veloci-Ramp-Tor 0.187
- 49 Arcane Maelstrom 0.186
See all 166 Commander precons ranked by least original →
What originality means here
Every card scores 0 to 1: one minus how close its nearest match anywhere in Magic gets, so 0.30 means something out there is 70% like it. A deck's figure is the average across its most original half of nonland cards, so it climbs by holding cards with less competition, never by holding more cards.
- 118 Arcane Maelstrom 0.186
- 119 Veloci-Ramp-Tor 0.187
- 120 Death Toll 0.188
- 121 Mutant Menace 0.188
- 122 Avengers Assemble 0.188
- 123 Upgrades Unleashed 0.189
- 124 Planar Portal 0.189
Most original cards
- Struggle for Project Purity 0.29
- Glowing One 0.29
- Screeching Scorchbeast 0.28
- The Wise Mothman 0.24
- Vault 12: The Necropolis 0.24
- Nightkin Ambusher 0.23
- Strength Bobblehead 0.23
- Fraying Sanity 0.22
- Nuka-Nuke Launcher 0.22
- Raul, Trouble Shooter 0.21
- Lily Bowen, Raging Grandma 0.20
- Infesting Radroach 0.20
- Tato Farmer 0.19
- The Master, Transcendent 0.19
- Rampaging Yao Guai 0.18
- Contaminated Drink 0.18
- Strong, the Brutish Thespian 0.17
- Jason Bright, Glowing Prophet 0.17
- Vault 87: Forced Evolution 0.17
- Power Fist 0.17
- Mirelurk Queen 0.16
- Lumbering Megasloth 0.16
- Find // Finality 0.15
- Agent Frank Horrigan 0.15
- Harold and Bob, First Numens 0.14
- Nuclear Fallout 0.13
- Watchful Radstag 0.13
- Feral Ghoul 0.12
- Bloatfly Swarm 0.12
- Inspiring Call 0.11
- Mutational Advantage 0.11
- Recon Craft Theta 0.11
- Inexorable Tide 0.11
- Atomize 0.10
- Tireless Tracker 0.10
- Guardian Project 0.09
- Winding Constrictor 0.07
- Vexing Radgull 0.06
- Alpha Deathclaw 0.06
- Biomass Mutation 0.06
- Hancock, Ghoulish Mayor 0.04
- Contagion Clasp 0.03
- Putrefy 0.03
- Cathedral Acolyte 0.02
- Farseek 0.02
- Marcus, Mutant Mayor 0.02
- Talisman of Curiosity 0.01
- Talisman of Dominance 0.01
- Talisman of Resilience 0.01
- Piper Wright, Publick Reporter 0.00
- Corpsejack Menace 0.00
- Harmonize 0.00
- Rampant Growth 0.00
- Arcane Signet 0.00
- Branching Evolution 0.00
- Casualties of War 0.00
- Cultivate 0.00
- Hardened Scales 0.00
- Radstorm 0.00
- Young Deathclaws 0.00
- Sol Ring -0.00
View these card images
See all 166 Commander precons ranked by saltiest →
What salt means here
EDHREC's annual survey asks players which cards they least enjoy facing, scoring each 0 to about 3: Stasis is 3.06, Rhystic Study 2.73, Mind Stone a flat 0. A deck's figure is those scores added up, so it gets there either through a few famous offenders or a long tail of mildly irritating ones. The one number here that is an opinion rather than a measurement.
- 48 Raining Cats and Dogs 24.4
- 49 Blame Game 24.4
- 50 Arcane Wizardry 24.3
- 51 Mutant Menace 24.3
- 52 Science! 24.2
- 53 Obscura Operation 24.2
- 54 Creative Energy 24.1
See all 166 Commander precons ranked by mildest →
What salt means here
EDHREC's annual survey asks players which cards they least enjoy facing, scoring each 0 to about 3: Stasis is 3.06, Rhystic Study 2.73, Mind Stone a flat 0. A deck's figure is those scores added up, so it gets there either through a few famous offenders or a long tail of mildly irritating ones. The one number here that is an opinion rather than a measurement.
- 113 Creative Energy 24.1
- 114 Obscura Operation 24.2
- 115 Science! 24.2
- 116 Mutant Menace 24.3
- 117 Arcane Wizardry 24.3
- 118 Blame Game 24.4
- 119 Raining Cats and Dogs 24.4
Saltiest cards
- Sol Ring 1.46
- The Wise Mothman 1.01
- Vault 12: The Necropolis 0.73
- Hancock, Ghoulish Mayor 0.67
- The Master, Transcendent 0.67
- Inexorable Tide 0.66
- Fraying Sanity 0.65
- Guardian Project 0.63
- Radstorm 0.58
- Glowing One 0.54
- Nightkin Ambusher 0.50
- Bloatfly Swarm 0.45
- Mutational Advantage 0.45
- Rampaging Yao Guai 0.45
- Branching Evolution 0.44
- Raul, Trouble Shooter 0.44
- Power Fist 0.43
- Hardened Scales 0.42
- Nuclear Fallout 0.42
- Piper Wright, Publick Reporter 0.41
- Casualties of War 0.40
- Command Tower 0.38
- Alpha Deathclaw 0.36
- Contagion Clasp 0.36
- Corpsejack Menace 0.35
- Marcus, Mutant Mayor 0.33
- Recon Craft Theta 0.33
- Screeching Scorchbeast 0.33
- Struggle for Project Purity 0.33
- Vault 87: Forced Evolution 0.33
- Contaminated Drink 0.31
- Agent Frank Horrigan 0.30
- Young Deathclaws 0.30
- Lumbering Megasloth 0.29
- Talisman of Curiosity 0.29
- Atomize 0.27
- Cathedral Acolyte 0.27
- Tireless Tracker 0.27
- Watchful Radstag 0.27
- Inspiring Call 0.26
- Arcane Signet 0.24
- Harold and Bob, First Numens 0.24
- Strength Bobblehead 0.22
- Darkwater Catacombs 0.21
- Mirelurk Queen 0.21
- Strong, the Brutish Thespian 0.21
- Vexing Radgull 0.21
- Cultivate 0.20
- Infesting Radroach 0.20
- Talisman of Dominance 0.20
- Feral Ghoul 0.19
- Rampant Growth 0.19
- Farseek 0.18
- Mariposa Military Base 0.18
- Putrefy 0.18
- Winding Constrictor 0.18
- Temple of the False God 0.17
- Tato Farmer 0.16
- Nesting Grounds 0.15
- Biomass Mutation 0.14
- Exotic Orchard 0.14
- Fetid Pools 0.14
- Find // Finality 0.14
- Overflowing Basin 0.14
- Evolving Wilds 0.13
- Path of Ancestry 0.13
- Ash Barrens 0.12
- Harmonize 0.12
- Mortuary Mire 0.11
- Temple of Deceit 0.11
- Temple of Mystery 0.11
- Sunken Hollow 0.10
- Tainted Wood 0.10
- Viridescent Bog 0.10
- Hinterland Harbor 0.08
- Temple of Malady 0.08
- Drowned Catacomb 0.05
- Opulent Palace 0.05
- Woodland Cemetery 0.05
- Tainted Isle 0.04
- Terramorphic Expanse 0.04
- Jason Bright, Glowing Prophet 0.00
- Lily Bowen, Raging Grandma 0.00
- Nuka-Nuke Launcher 0.00
- Talisman of Resilience 0.00
View these card images
See all 166 Commander precons ranked by most expensive →
What of cards means here
The cheapest paper printing of every card, added together: what the hundred cards cost to own as singles, not what the sealed box sells for. That is why one reserved list card can put a deck above four decks of staples. Basic lands count toward the total but are left out of the card list below, since thirty Islands are not what anyone means by a deck's cheapest cards.
- 19 Entropic Uprising $137.80
- 20 Draconic Domination $136.29
- 21 Sliver Swarm $135.09
- 22 Mutant Menace $135.04
- 23 Fae Dominion $132.99
- 24 Exit from Exile $132.29
- 25 Timeless Wisdom $131.43
See all 166 Commander precons ranked by cheapest →
What of cards means here
The cheapest paper printing of every card, added together: what the hundred cards cost to own as singles, not what the sealed box sells for. That is why one reserved list card can put a deck above four decks of staples. Basic lands count toward the total but are left out of the card list below, since thirty Islands are not what anyone means by a deck's cheapest cards.
- 142 Timeless Wisdom $131.43
- 143 Exit from Exile $132.29
- 144 Fae Dominion $132.99
- 145 Mutant Menace $135.04
- 146 Sliver Swarm $135.09
- 147 Draconic Domination $136.29
- 148 Entropic Uprising $137.80
Priciest cards
- Power Fist $14.75
- Guardian Project $12.96
- Rampaging Yao Guai $10.31
- Atomize $9.44
- Branching Evolution $6.67
- Mutational Advantage $6.51
- Agent Frank Horrigan $5.63
- Radstorm $5.58
- Strength Bobblehead $5.31
- Struggle for Project Purity $4.39
- Nuclear Fallout $3.18
- Bloatfly Swarm $2.68
- Feral Ghoul $2.55
- Recon Craft Theta $2.29
- Hardened Scales $2.26
- Glowing One $2.18
- Infesting Radroach $2.12
- Alpha Deathclaw $2.11
- Screeching Scorchbeast $2.04
- Tainted Isle $1.61
- Hancock, Ghoulish Mayor $1.56
- Watchful Radstag $1.45
- Sol Ring $1.36
- Talisman of Dominance $1.24
- Drowned Catacomb $1.23
- Raul, Trouble Shooter $1.22
- Inexorable Tide $1.04
- Mirelurk Queen $1.00
- Tato Farmer $0.97
- The Master, Transcendent $0.96
- Vexing Radgull $0.90
- Marcus, Mutant Mayor $0.89
- Cathedral Acolyte $0.81
- Vault 12: The Necropolis $0.68
- Lily Bowen, Raging Grandma $0.63
- Fraying Sanity $0.50
- Woodland Cemetery $0.50
- Winding Constrictor $0.48
- Farseek $0.45
- Arcane Signet $0.39
- Talisman of Resilience $0.39
- The Wise Mothman $0.39
- Jason Bright, Glowing Prophet $0.37
- Nuka-Nuke Launcher $0.36
- Rampant Growth $0.36
- Young Deathclaws $0.36
- Cultivate $0.35
- Contagion Clasp $0.34
- Contaminated Drink $0.34
- Lumbering Megasloth $0.34
- Piper Wright, Publick Reporter $0.34
- Talisman of Curiosity $0.33
- Nightkin Ambusher $0.32
- Strong, the Brutish Thespian $0.32
- Harold and Bob, First Numens $0.31
- Mariposa Military Base $0.31
- Vault 87: Forced Evolution $0.31
- Corpsejack Menace $0.30
- Sunken Hollow $0.30
- Tainted Wood $0.30
- Darkwater Catacombs $0.29
- Inspiring Call $0.29
- Hinterland Harbor $0.28
- Nesting Grounds $0.28
- Mortuary Mire $0.27
- Opulent Palace $0.27
- Casualties of War $0.26
- Viridescent Bog $0.26
- Fetid Pools $0.25
- Exotic Orchard $0.23
- Path of Ancestry $0.22
- Tireless Tracker $0.22
- Command Tower $0.20
- Find // Finality $0.19
- Harmonize $0.19
- Ash Barrens $0.18
- Temple of the False God $0.18
- Biomass Mutation $0.17
- Overflowing Basin $0.17
- Temple of Deceit $0.16
- Temple of Malady $0.16
- Putrefy $0.15
- Temple of Mystery $0.14
- Terramorphic Expanse $0.13
- Evolving Wilds $0.10
View these card images
See all 166 Commander precons ranked by most played cards →
What median play rate means here
EDHREC ranks every card by how many Commander decks run it, #1 being the most played in the format. A deck's figure is the median rank across its nonland cards, so #1200 means half this deck sits inside the format's twelve hundred most played cards. A smaller number is the deck built out of staples.
- 97 Entropic Uprising #3967
- 98 Grave Danger #4119
- 99 Feline Ferocity #4126
- 100 Mutant Menace #4134
- 101 Guided By Nature #4141
- 102 Creative Energy #4288
- 103 Stalwart Unity #4293
See all 166 Commander precons ranked by least played cards →
What median play rate means here
EDHREC ranks every card by how many Commander decks run it, #1 being the most played in the format. A deck's figure is the median rank across its nonland cards, so #1200 means half this deck sits inside the format's twelve hundred most played cards. A smaller number is the deck built out of staples.
- 64 Stalwart Unity #4293
- 65 Creative Energy #4288
- 66 Guided By Nature #4141
- 67 Mutant Menace #4134
- 68 Feline Ferocity #4126
- 69 Grave Danger #4119
- 70 Entropic Uprising #3967
Most played cards
- Sol Ring #1
- Arcane Signet #3
- Cultivate #20
- Farseek #23
- Rampant Growth #26
- Talisman of Dominance #93
- Hardened Scales #185
- Inspiring Call #277
- Guardian Project #321
- Harmonize #325
- Putrefy #336
- Branching Evolution #370
- Talisman of Curiosity #484
- Talisman of Resilience #497
- Tireless Tracker #657
- Inexorable Tide #1034
- Contagion Clasp #1422
- Corpsejack Menace #1557
- Power Fist #1806
- Casualties of War #1819
- Mutational Advantage #2019
- Winding Constrictor #2074
- Atomize #2090
- Struggle for Project Purity #2772
- Fraying Sanity #2881
- Rampaging Yao Guai #2954
- Nuclear Fallout #3054
- Radstorm #3074
- Agent Frank Horrigan #3504
- The Wise Mothman #3691
- Mirelurk Queen #4134
- Feral Ghoul #4150
- Screeching Scorchbeast #4214
- Tato Farmer #4361
- Glowing One #4558
- Vexing Radgull #4745
- Biomass Mutation #4859
- Infesting Radroach #5060
- The Master, Transcendent #5237
- Bloatfly Swarm #5335
- Alpha Deathclaw #5443
- Raul, Trouble Shooter #5565
- Find // Finality #5588
- Recon Craft Theta #5918
- Strength Bobblehead #6062
- Strong, the Brutish Thespian #6161
- Watchful Radstag #6287
- Piper Wright, Publick Reporter #6300
- Hancock, Ghoulish Mayor #6398
- Cathedral Acolyte #6439
- Marcus, Mutant Mayor #6554
- Vault 12: The Necropolis #6615
- Lily Bowen, Raging Grandma #6999
- Nightkin Ambusher #7165
- Nuka-Nuke Launcher #7197
- Contaminated Drink #8548
- Harold and Bob, First Numens #8903
- Jason Bright, Glowing Prophet #8959
- Vault 87: Forced Evolution #11197
- Young Deathclaws #11590
- Lumbering Megasloth #11745
View these card images
See all 166 Commander precons ranked by oldest →
What a card on average means here
How long ago each card was first printed, averaged across the deck. A reprint does not make an old card new, so a deck published last year and stuffed with reprints still reads old. The total underneath is every card's age added together; the ranking uses the average, because a sum quietly rewards the bigger deck for being bigger.
- 153 Masters of Evil 8.9 years
- 154 Hail, Caesar 8.9 years
- 155 Lorehold Spirit 8.9 years
- 156 Mutant Menace 8.8 years
- 157 Prismari Artistry 8.6 years
- 158 Witherbloom Pestilence 8.5 years
- 159 Quandrix Unlimited 8.5 years
See all 166 Commander precons ranked by newest →
What a card on average means here
How long ago each card was first printed, averaged across the deck. A reprint does not make an old card new, so a deck published last year and stuffed with reprints still reads old. The total underneath is every card's age added together; the ranking uses the average, because a sum quietly rewards the bigger deck for being bigger.
- 8 Quandrix Unlimited 8.5 years
- 9 Witherbloom Pestilence 8.5 years
- 10 Prismari Artistry 8.6 years
- 11 Mutant Menace 8.8 years
- 12 Lorehold Spirit 8.9 years
- 13 Hail, Caesar 8.9 years
- 14 Masters of Evil 8.9 years
Oldest cards
- Sol Ring 33.1 years
- Rampant Growth 29.9 years
- Darkwater Catacombs 25.0 years
- Tainted Isle 24.6 years
- Tainted Wood 24.6 years
- Temple of the False God 23.3 years
- Talisman of Dominance 23.0 years
- Terramorphic Expanse 21.1 years
- Farseek 20.9 years
- Putrefy 20.9 years
- Harmonize 19.6 years
- Exotic Orchard 17.6 years
- Drowned Catacomb 17.2 years
- Evolving Wilds 16.4 years
- Cultivate 16.2 years
- Contagion Clasp 16.0 years
- Inexorable Tide 16.0 years
- Command Tower 15.2 years
- Hinterland Harbor 15.0 years
- Woodland Cemetery 15.0 years
- Corpsejack Menace 13.9 years
- Biomass Mutation 13.6 years
- Temple of Deceit 13.0 years
- Temple of Mystery 13.0 years
- Temple of Malady 12.4 years
- Hardened Scales 12.0 years
- Opulent Palace 12.0 years
- Inspiring Call 11.5 years
- Mortuary Mire 11.0 years
- Sunken Hollow 11.0 years
- Tireless Tracker 10.4 years
- Ash Barrens 9.8 years
- Winding Constrictor 9.7 years
- Fetid Pools 9.4 years
- Fraying Sanity 9.2 years
- Path of Ancestry 9.1 years
- Find // Finality 7.9 years
- Guardian Project 7.6 years
- Casualties of War 7.4 years
- Talisman of Curiosity 7.3 years
- Talisman of Resilience 7.3 years
- Arcane Signet 7.0 years
- Nesting Grounds 6.4 years
- Branching Evolution 6.2 years
- Agent Frank Horrigan 2.5 years
- Alpha Deathclaw 2.5 years
- Atomize 2.5 years
- Bloatfly Swarm 2.5 years
- Cathedral Acolyte 2.5 years
- Contaminated Drink 2.5 years
- Feral Ghoul 2.5 years
- Glowing One 2.5 years
- Hancock, Ghoulish Mayor 2.5 years
- Harold and Bob, First Numens 2.5 years
- Infesting Radroach 2.5 years
- Jason Bright, Glowing Prophet 2.5 years
- Lily Bowen, Raging Grandma 2.5 years
- Lumbering Megasloth 2.5 years
- Marcus, Mutant Mayor 2.5 years
- Mariposa Military Base 2.5 years
- Mirelurk Queen 2.5 years
- Mutational Advantage 2.5 years
- Nightkin Ambusher 2.5 years
- Nuclear Fallout 2.5 years
- Nuka-Nuke Launcher 2.5 years
- Overflowing Basin 2.5 years
- Piper Wright, Publick Reporter 2.5 years
- Power Fist 2.5 years
- Radstorm 2.5 years
- Rampaging Yao Guai 2.5 years
- Raul, Trouble Shooter 2.5 years
- Recon Craft Theta 2.5 years
- Screeching Scorchbeast 2.5 years
- Strength Bobblehead 2.5 years
- Strong, the Brutish Thespian 2.5 years
- Struggle for Project Purity 2.5 years
- Tato Farmer 2.5 years
- The Master, Transcendent 2.5 years
- The Wise Mothman 2.5 years
- Vault 12: The Necropolis 2.5 years
- Vault 87: Forced Evolution 2.5 years
- Vexing Radgull 2.5 years
- Viridescent Bog 2.5 years
- Watchful Radstag 2.5 years
- Young Deathclaws 2.5 years
View these card images
What the figures on each card mean
- Originality
- One minus how close the card's nearest match anywhere in Magic gets, so a card at 0.30 has something out there 70% like it.
- Play rate
- EDHREC's rank for how often the card is played in Commander, where #1 is the most played card in the format.
- Salt
- Out of about 3, from EDHREC's salt survey, where players vote on the cards they least enjoy facing.
- Card age
- How long ago the card was first printed, counted from its earliest printing, so a reprint does not make an old card new.
Every ranking here is against the other 165 Commander precons, measured the same way for all of them. Read your own deck through the same lens →